18 May 2020

This week’s puzzle

This week is another area problem. Take a rectangle ABCD (as shown here). Draw two lines from the adjacent vertices A and D to two random points E and F on the opposite side such that they intersect within the rectangle. See picture below. Nothing is drawn to scale. The area of the two triangles are 4 and 16. One of the quadrilaterals has an area of 10. What is the area of the other quadrilateral?

Again, this is geometry from elementary school with a twist to it.

Note that the original version of the problem that I had posted had the quadrilateral area as 1 instead of 10. Harmindar Matharu successfully proved that such a diagram is not possible. I should have been more careful while picking some values for those areas…



Posted May 18, 2020 by Rajib Roy in category "Puzzles

7 COMMENTS :

  1. By Harmindar on

    Area of the other quadrilateral = 16 + 4 – 1 = 19

    Reply
  2. By Harmindar Matharu on

    The area of the other quadrilateral = 16 + 4 – 1 = 19

    Reply
  3. By Rajib Roy (Post author) on

    Harmindar, it will probably be far less than that. How did you get to the relationship that the sum of the triangles is the same as the sum of the quadrilaterals?

    Reply
  4. By Harmindar Mathar on

    Move move the point F to B and move the point E to C, you get four triangles with equal areas. Move the points F and E to be at the same place, you get three triangles, one with side AD having area equal to the sum of the other two. This gave me the relationship that sum of two opposing triangles is same as the sum of the other two remaining triangles or the quadrilaterals.

    Reply
  5. By Rajib Roy (Post author) on

    Got it! I can see how in those two extreme cases, the logic holds. But there is no proof that it holds for other points too. In fact, it does not, actually.

    (Also, I am not sure why your comments have to be approved everytime. I will look into it).

    Reply
  6. By Rajib Roy (Post author) on

    Have to callout Harmindar for his tenacity. Had a private exchange with him. He came very close.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.